Don’t forge documents. Avoid unauthorized trading. Don’t give false or misleading information. Don't spill secrets about client assets to your neighbors. Above all, don’t steal or “borrow” your clients’ money. These practices are all standard protocols for financial advisors—or at least those that don't get visits from the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission's Division of Enforcement. However, there are other less obvious tips that can help you avoid getting sued as a financial advisor.
Even the most diligent pr🌌ofessionals can find themselves vulnerable to legal challenges. From disgruntled clients claiming mismanagement of funds to allegations of discriminatory practices in hiring and promotion, the spectrum of potential legal threats is broad. For smaller advisory firm༒s that lack the extensive legal resources of larger institutions, the threat of lawsuits can be particularly daunting.
Crystal McKeon, a certified financial planner and chief compliance officer at TSA Wealth Management in Houston, Texas, said an important strategy for avoiding and defending yourself from litigation is to document everything. "Having a robust and actively used customer relations management system where you can document conversations and recommendations shared with clients" is crucial, she said. "So often things get confused or forgotten over the years, and if you are not documenting your conversations, you have no backup that what you think you said was actually what you said."
Key Takeaways
- Financial advising can be a lucrative and rewarding career, helping clients achieve their financial goals. Sometimes, however, recommendations don't turn out well and your client may lose money—ultimately blaming you.
- Regularly update clients on their portfolio performance, market changes, and any adjustments to their financial strategy. Ensure that clients fully understand the risks associated with their investments and have realistic expectations about potential outcomes.
- Comprehensive documentation serves as a crucial defense if there's a lawsuit, providing evidence of your professional conduct and the rationale behind your recommendations.
- If a lawsuit is brought, consider mediation to potentially find a mutually agreeable outcome.
- A culture of integrity not only reduces the risk of lawsuits but also builds trust with clients and enhances your firm's reputation in the long run.
Below, we'll explore these and other essential safeguards for you and your firm, from robust documentation practices and clear communication protocols to comprehensive insurance coverage and ongoing education on regulatory compliance. Consider these 10 tips to avoid becoming a cautionary tale or, worse, the subject of a panel discussion at a compliance officer conference.
Tip 1: Ensure You🍒 Have a Full Picture of Your Clients
As an investment advisor, you have a fiduciary duty 🐼to act in your clients’ best interests, to put their interests above your own, and to give advice based on complete and accurate information.
You should get complete and accurate information from clients through interviews, questionnaires, records, and documents, including 💖tax returns and bank statements. If they give you incomplete or inaccurate information, you may offer the🔯m incorrect or inaccurate financial advice.
Fast Fact
In 2023, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) received just over 11,000 investor complaints—less than the 14,311 received two years earlier but far greater than in 2020 and the years before.
The Certified Financial Planner Board’s practice standards state that advisors who cannot get the information they need should “either limit the scope of engagement to those services the CFP professional is able to provide or terminate the engagement.” Even if you aren't a CFP, this is simply good practice.
Clients may be embarrassed about their financial position or by how they 𝕴got their money. It may be easier to encourage clients to disclose this private information if you remind them that financial advisors are to keep their information confidential.
If you are a CFP, this obligation must be stated in writing. The best way to provide a great service and keep clients happy is to know as much as possible about their finances and about aspects of their personal and business lives that affect their finances.
Tip 2: Provide Comple𒐪te and Accurate Profes♋sional Disclosures
Just as you expect your𒁃 clients to disclose certain information to you, regulators expect you to reveal all important information a client needs to make an informed decision about working with a professional and taking their advice.
Clients need to know about any past or potential conflicts of interest, the risks in the strategies you use to choose investments,♏ and any unusual risks posed by a particular investment or strategy you might recommenꦗd. They also need to know if you’ve been disciplined or sued in the past.
FINRA Fines and Restitution
In 2023, FINRA collected $88.4 million in fines and $7.5 million in restitution, but in 2021, they collected $103 million in fines and $47 million in restitution.
All this information and more should be compiled in a detailed document for your client per the brochure rule (or ওa similar state-level rule if you’re regulaꦗted at the state rather than the federal level).
Provide a copy to each client and ask them to sign a form stating that they’ve received it and reviewed it, and keep that as part of your records. Besides meeting your legal requirements, by providing this information 🍨to clients upfront, you can cut your risk of being sued and present a stronger defense if that should happen.
Tip 3: Communicate Clearly
Beyond legally mandated disclosures, it's important to communicate in clear, unambiguous language. Experts stress the importance of spelling things out for clients in layman's terms. For instance, when describing an investment as "liquid," it's prudent to write out specific details, such as the ability to sell the investment for a certain number of years.
Similarly, when discussing risk tolerance, it's crucial to quantify what outcomes the client would find tolerable, as terms like "moderate risk" can be ambiguous and open to interpretation. This level of clarity and specificity in communication can significantly cut down on misunderstandings that could lead to legal disputes.
In addition, while you might be frustrated because you’re making a recommendation that you know is in their best interest, you should never push a client into an investment, strategy, or financial product that could later cause a client to feel cheated or misled. Those are two things that are likely to get you sued or pr♋ompt a client to file a regulatory complaint against you.
That being said, while it may be easy to avoid investing a client’s money in something obviously unsuitඣable, it’s harder to know what to do when a client wants to retire in 20 years but is afraid to invest in stocks to build the needed nest egg.
This is where education comes in. You may be able to gradually increase their risk tolerance by in꧃creasing their financial literacy. However, you can’t push them before they’re read✅y.
♏Tip🎉 4: Keep Client Information Safe From Cyber Attacks
Keeping your clients' information safe from cyberattacks is critical. Financial advisors are natural targets for hackers because they manage large amounts of money and a variety of people's personal information. As an advisor, it is your duty to be diligent about checking the security of all your third-party vendors.
Tip 5: Avoid Conflicts of Interest and Se⭕lf-Interested Advice
While building close relationships with clients is positive, it's crucial to maintain professional boundaries. Engaging in side business deals with clients or entering into personal financial arrangements is not advisable. Financial advisors are also advised to refrain from lending money to clients, borrowing their property, or accepting extravagant gifts. Even romantic relationships with clients, while not illegal, can be problematic and should be approached with caution.
When unsure about a potential conflict of interest, consult your compliance team. If you're hesitant to do so, you already know it's best to avoid the situation.
Financial advisors should also be cautious about selling commission-driven products without appropriate disclosure or encouraging clients to donate to charities where the advisor serves on the board.
Tip 6: Diligently Train Your Employees
Your safeguards against lawsuits are only as strong as your least-trained employees. In addition to training employees to keep your clients' information safe, your employees should know the best practices in client relationships. Supervise all members of your business so that you know how they handle client information and the kinds of investment recommendations they make.
One way to prevent significant mistakes that put you at risk is to have a lead or senior advisor sign off on all major plans and actions. Ensure that your employees set client expectations appropriately and don't make promises you can’t reasonably deliver on.
Tip 7: Avoid High-Risk Clients
Yo❀u don’t have to take on every potential client who approaches you. You might spot during an initial phone conversation or meeting. Perhaps they're not forthcoming about their financial situation, don’t want to review or complete paperwork, or show signs that another family member has too much influence over their finances𝄹.
You might not want to get involved with someone who seemsꦕ reluctant to cooperate, has unreasonably high expectations, or may pressure yཧou into committing unethical acts. Not only may these clients be difficult to work with, but your relationship with them can soon affect those you have with other clients.
Tip 8: Get the Right Insurance Coverage
Financial advisors need 澳洲幸运5开奖号码历史查询:errors and omissions insurance 🐬to protect themselves against claims that clients might bring for negligence, breach of fiduciary duty, or lack of regulatory compliance. Liability insurance can keep you from going out of business by paying for your legal defense, regardless of your guilt, and covering certain lℱosses if you are found at fault. Ensure your policy covers your employees, too. In addition, you can look into adding cyber liability insurance, which can offer another layer of protection if there's a breach of confidential data.
Tip 9: Listen to and Check In on Your Clients
Do your clients understand investment risks and the possibility that their money won't grow substantially yearly? You'll need to provide a 澳洲幸运5开奖号码历史查询:boilerplate disclosure about investment risks for your clients to sign before you can work with them. It should explain that investing in securities involves the risk of losing capital, that🅺 there is no guaranteed investment, and that past performance doesn't guarantee future results.
Clients might just skim the disclosure before signing it if they read it at all. They might also underestimate their risk tolerance. That’s why, rather than asking vague questions such as “How much risk tolerance do you have?” it can be more helpful to ask questions such as “How would you react if your retirement portfolio lost 25% of its value in one year? Would you want to sell some of your investments, do nothing, or buy?"
FINRA Suspensions
In 2023, 257 individuals were suspended as financial advisors and 178 were barred from the industry. These figures were a significant decline in the number of punishments handed down by FINRA from the 733 individuals suspended and 492 barred in 2017.
Clients without much investment experience might overestimate how well they would market declines. Learning about their investment history and how past experiences with money have shap🍷ed their views is essential.
Just because a client has the financial capacity to absorb a certain level of risk doesn’t mean they have the psychological ability to do so. It’s also helpful to give clients a basic investment education, even if your client wants to be hands-off.🐻 This helps 🌃them understand your approach and your recommendations.
In addition, you'll want to offer regular and understandable account statements to your clients, along with a written summary of what has changed since the last statement. Follow up by asking your client if they’ve reviewed the statement and have any questions.
Ask them if their portfolio is performing in line with their expectations. By doing thesᩚᩚᩚᩚᩚᩚᩚᩚᩚ𒀱ᩚᩚᩚe things, you will stay on top of how your clients feel about their investments and your advice. Being assertive in this way can help you get ahead of any problems.
Checking in regularly also allows you to adjust your client’s portfolio and investment strategy as their life changes. Being aware of family, health, and job c🅘hanges is especially important.
Tip 10: Provide Investment Policy St🔯atements to Your Clients
In addition to providing clients with a basic level of investment education, you need them to understand why you recommend particular investments and asset allocations. An investment policy statement (IPS) provided by your firm can help.
A written IPS puts front and center how and why a portfolio will be invested in certain securities. Ask your client to sign off on the plan before you touch their money. Not only will you protect yourself, you'll also be taking an important step toward improving transparency and trust in your client-advisor relationship.
How Can Mediation Help Avoid Litigation for a Financial Advisor?
If a client threatens a lawsuit and you can’t resolve the problem on your own, propose 澳洲幸运5开奖号码历史查询:mediation. This is an informal, voluntary process where a neutral third party will help you and your client find a mutually aꦿgreeable solution using a faster and cheaper method than arbitrati🍃on or litigation.
The FINRA mediation process has an excellent success rate of resolving four out of five cases. Assure your client that they don’t have to accept the settlement if they choose mediation. Theꩲy keep their right to arbitrate or litigate if the mediator can’t find a mutually satisfactory outcome.
How Can Financial Advisors Ensure Compliance With Regulations To Avoid Litigation?
Financial advisors must ensure they follow the relevant regulations to avoid litigation. This involves staying updated on regulatory changes and industry best practices and attending continuing education programs. Also, putting in place and ensuring you follow robust 澳洲幸运5开奖号码历史查询:compliance programs within your firm are essential. Advisors should also cond𒁃uct regular audits to identify and cor⛎rect any potential compliance issues before they become a problem.
How Can Financial Advisors Ensure They follow Anti-Discrimination Laws To Avoid Litigation?
Financial advisors can ensure compliance with 澳洲幸运5开奖号码历史查询:anti-discrimination laws by imp♏lementing diversity and inclusion policies, providing regular training on anti-discrimination laws, and encouraging an inclusive workplace culture.
Advisors should familiarize themselves with relevant laws such as 澳洲幸运5开奖号码历史查询:Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, the Americans with Disabilities Act, and the Equal Pay Act, among others. In addition, maintaining detailed records of hiring, promotion, and client interaction processes can help demonstrate compliance and prevent discrimination claims.
The Bottom Line
Even the most conscientious advisor can get sued. When even the most soundly constructed 澳洲幸运5开奖号码历史查询:portfolio loses money, a distressed customer may look for a scapegoat and a way to recoup their lo🎃sses by calling a lawyer and looking for wrongdoing. Or they m𓃲ay simply be confused about something you've done.
You can mitigate the risk of ൩client disputes escalating into litigation by fostering clear and open communication with clients. This includes setting realistic expectations, thoroughly explaining investment strategies, and regularly updating clients on their portfolio performance. In addition, maintaining detailed records of all client interactions and decisions can provide crucial evidence when disputes arise. Advisors should also consider including arbitration clauses in client agreements, which can offer a less adversarial and more cost-effective means of resolving disputes than litigation.